I haven't tried the new ones ( which I assume are the best -> banana nut muffin / chocolate chip cookie dough ) but I liked the coconut one, peanut butter chocolate, cinnamon roll, strawberry cheese cake, apple pie.. list goes on ... Heck the only one I actually didn't love was the lemon flavoured one. Top 3 ( the ones I've tried this far) peanut butter chocolate/coconut/vanilla almond crunch.
I was looking to buy a few boxes ( try 10! ) myself! Been waiting for some kind of an offer from predator for some while to be honest but if not maybe they could give some personal discount if I'd buy say 10 boxes? ^^